767 policies & templates from £99.90 Explore the full library

When a protected conversation doesn’t go to plan

A client recently came to me feeling stuck. They had an underperforming employee who’d been on a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) for several months with little change. After trying to open a protected conversation to explore a mutual exit, the employee simply refused to engage—leaving the business unsure what to do next.

When a protected conversation doesn’t go to plan

They wanted to act fairly, avoid unnecessary conflict, and stay within the law. I guided them through their options step by step, using my ER Toolkit and templates to make the process more manageable.

Step 1: Review and Reframe

We began by reviewing the performance records—including the original PIP, meeting notes, and any informal support offered. Everything was well documented and consistent, so we had a solid foundation.

Next, I helped the client reframe their approach.

Premium content

Continue reading the full success story

Get the complete HR strategy, documentation approach, risks considered and final outcome by upgrading your access.

Get started today

HR confidence starts here

Whether you employ 5 people or 50, hrdocbox.co.uk gives you the structure, documents and expertise needed to manage employees professionally and legally.

Download your FREE UK employment contract template

Professionally written and fully compliant with UK employment law

Download FREE contract
Free UK employment contract template